By way of distraction: Studdert Kennedy on the Blessed Trinity

Tue, 03/07/2012 - 19:17

I am sitting in the library at the London School of Theology trying to cobble together a book proposal. Looking for distraction I have just pulled off the shelf beside me The Wicket Gate by G.A. Studdert Kennedy, first published in 1923. Opening the book more or less at random I happened upon this entertaining comment on the lines “I believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, and Giver of Life, Who proceedeth from the Father and the Son” from the Nicene Creed:

Merely reading the history of this clause of the Creed makes one’s brain reel, and the cold sweat of utter bewilderment breaks out upon one’s brow, as one strives to follow the very human doctors of Divinity in their efforts to settle the exact relationship of the persons of the Blessed Trinity. No sooner does one escape from one heresy, than another bites one in the back; and the last state is worse than the first. Mr. G.K. Chesterton, in a fine passage of his “Orthodoxy,” draws a picture of Orthodoxy as a splendid, swaying figure, standing upon two wild, but superbly-controlled horses, and sweeping down the course of time with the sprawling heresies lying prone on either side. But the attempt to be orthodox on the subject of the Blessed Trinity, and at the same time intelligible, makes one feel not so much like a gallant rider of fiery steeds, as like hen on a hot riddle, only safe when one is in the air.

Comments

“When modern readers are introduced to the theological debates of the fourth and fifth centuries, they are sometimes shocked by the atmosphere in which they took place. Those debates were not carried on by calm scholars sitting in their manuscript-lined studies. From one perspective, the story is one of misunderstandings, vicious personal attacks, distortions, violence, bribes, mutual excommunication, intervention by emperors, and the deposition and exile of bishops and others who lost in the struggle. From another perspective, the story is one of theological creativity that has shaped Christian beliefs for about fifteen centuries.” –Joseph H. Lynch, Early Christianity: A Brief History (Oxford: Oxford University Press 2010), 161.

A nice review. Worth reading. Thanks.

At random...

The parable of the mustard seed Jesus’ image of a tree in which birds make their nests (cf. Matt. 13:32; Lk. 13:19) recalls passages in the Old Testament in which Babylon and Egypt are depicted as trees that provide a home for the birds of the air and shelter for the...
Emerging ecclesiology in crisis I have been meaning for some time to respond to some comments made by Jason Clark to the effect that the emerging church lacks a coherent ecclesiology. He was commenting on a piece I wrote four years ago asking: What does the emerging...
Who was Jesus? Here’s an extraordinary insight into the historical Jesus from an ancient source that is unquestionably independent of the Gospels. The historian Josephus, writing a few years after the disastrous Jewish uprising against Roman occupation,...